Make Your Working Papers Work: Comparing Top Tools

8min Read

The world is going digital fast, and accounting firms need smart tools to keep up and thrive. Finding the right technology partner for working papers is crucial in this shift, acting as the backbone of modern accounting practices. 

> 60% of midsize firms saying that tech and automation are key to their growth, picking the right tool can make all the difference in staying competitive. 

However, choosing the right tool takes careful consideration of all the features. It’s also important to choose a tool that is flexible to your needs, and not one that your accounting firm has to adapt to be able to use.

In light of this, let’s see how two leading digital working paper softwares, Silverfin and MyWorkpapers, weigh up against each other in solving key accounting problems. 

What Are the Main Problems They Solve?

Choosing the right tool means understanding the problems it addresses. Silverfin is an obvious MyWorkpapers alternative as both have solid cloud credentials and connect with a wide range of client bookkeeping systems through open APIs.

Silverfin 

Accounting firms often struggle with wasted time tracking down or working on outdated data. Staff get frustrated with repetitive tasks and manual data updates, and inconsistencies in file preparation and review can cause major headaches. Fragmented communication between colleagues and clients further complicates matters, and delayed or incomplete reporting can hinder advisory services.

Silverfin helps  to address these issues:

  • Centralised Client Data: Keeps all client data in one place, facilitating easy access and integration across various workflows.
  • Automation of Compliance Processes: Streamlines and automates compliance tasks, cutting down on manual effort and boosting accuracy. In fact, with Silverfin, you can cut down year-end preparations and corporation tax submissions by up to 50% with automation, AI data checking and in-context communications.

MyWorkpapers 

Accounting can be complex, especially during audits and year-end processes. Recently acquired by tax, accounting and payroll software company, Bright, MyWorkpapers offers robust solutions to streamline these tasks, making it easier for accountants to manage their workload and collaborate effectively:

  • Simplified Audit and Year-End Processes: Provides tools to standardise and automate audit and year-end tasks, reducing errors and enhancing efficiency.
  • Enhanced Collaboration: Secure portals facilitate seamless document exchange and communication between clients and other accounting firms.

RELATED: Is AI-powered accounting software better than Excel for modern firms?

Ease of Use

No one wants to struggle with clunky software. Ease of use can make or break your experience with a tool.

Silverfin 

Navigating complex accounting tasks becomes a breeze with Silverfin’s user-friendly design. Developed by accountants for accountants, the intuitive interface simplifies even the most intricate processes:

  • Cloud-based, user-friendly interface designed to be intuitive and easy to navigate.
  • Integrated communication tools make collaboration straightforward and efficient, eliminating the need for external communication channels.

MyWorkpapers 

MyWorkpapers prides itself on its cloud-first, user-centric design. Features like PDF annotation and Excel integration make it accessible for both tech-savvy users and those more comfortable with traditional tools:

  • Intuitive platform with features like PDF annotation and Excel integration, making it user-friendly.
  • Smooth transition to digital processes, thanks to familiar tools and interfaces, making it easy for users to adapt.

Time Savings

Time is money, especially in accounting. The right tool can save you hours of work.

Silverfin 

Silverfin’s automated processes are designed to save time and ensure accuracy at every step. By leveraging live data syncs and automated reconciliations, manual data entry is drastically reduced. Additionally, the AI-powered Silverfin Assistant helps make sure the data is accurate:

  • Automatically synchronises data, eliminating the need for repetitive manual entry.
  • Uses AI to detect discrepancies and errors, cutting down the time spent on manual checks and freeing up accountants for more strategic work.

MyWorkpapers 

MyWorkpapers is all about efficiency. By automating key processes, it helps accountants complete their tasks faster:

  • Automated solutions for year-end and audit processes significantly reduce preparation time.
  • Centralised data and automated workflows streamline operations and eliminate redundant tasks, allowing accountants to focus on higher-value activities.

Flexibility

Every firm is different. It is important to choose a tool that allows you to tailor workflows to suit your specific needs.

Silverfin

Silverfin provides substantial flexibility by offering adaptable workflows and templates that match the unique needs of your accounting firm. This adaptability means you can tailor reports and management accounts to specific client needs, enhancing overall efficiency.

  • Tailor workflows and templates to suit your accounting firm and the specific needs of the various types of clients you work with.
  • Support for all major Client Types, with templates designed to support limited companies, LLPs, sole traders, and partnerships. Continuous software updates reflect regulatory changes, keeping you up-to-date and compliant.

MyWorkpapers 

MyWorkpapers also understands the need for personalisation. Its customisable templates and processes ensure that it meets the specific requirements of different client types and firm structures:

  • Offers standard and customisable templates for various client types and accounting firm sizes.
  • Personalise processes and integrate with existing tools like Excel with Excel Connect, for a more customised experience, making it a versatile choice for diverse accounting needs.

RELATED: Unlocking Potential: A Guide to Selecting the Right AI Accountant Software

Integrations

Integration capabilities can greatly enhance the functionality of your accounting tool, making it more powerful.

Silverfin 

Silverfin shines with its extensive integration capabilities. It works seamlessly with major bookkeeping systems and offers open APIs for added flexibility:

  • Seamlessly integrates with major bookkeeping systems such as Xero, QuickBooks, and Sage.
  • Open APIs facilitate easy connectivity with other software, enhancing its versatility and making it a comprehensive solution for accounting firms.

MyWorkpapers 

MyWorkpapers connects with a wide range of software, ensuring that it fits into your existing tech stack without any hassle:

  • Integrates with a wide range of software, including IRIS, Sage Accounting, and QuickBooks.
  • Features secure client and firm portals for document exchange and collaboration, adding an extra layer of functionality and security.

AI Data Analysis for Checking Discrepancies

AI is a growing part of accounting and can revolutionise the accuracy and efficiency of your accounting processes.

Silverfin 

Silverfin leverages AI to enhance its data analysis capabilities. Silverfin Assistant continuously monitors data, providing error reporting for accountants and suggesting fixes:

  • The Silverfin Assistant uses AI to analyse data, identify discrepancies, and suggest fixes, enhancing accuracy.
  • Continuous AI monitoring ensures that data remains accurate and reliable, reducing errors and improving overall data quality.

MyWorkpapers 

MyWorkpapers also identifies AI as a valuable tool for better data accuracy and has plans to incorporate AI in the future. 

RELATED: How Accounting Intelligence Can Give Your Firm a Competitive Advantage

Pricing

Cost is always a consideration. The right tool should offer value for money.

Silverfin 

Silverfin offers flexible pricing that can scale with your firm’s needs. This makes it accessible for firms of all sizes, providing great value:

  • Flexible per client file pricing, suitable for firms of all sizes.
  • Value-based pricing that scales with your firm’s growth and needs, ensuring that you only pay for what you use.

MyWorkpapers 

MyWorkpapers offers a variety of pricing plans to cater to different firm sizes and requirements. Its transparent pricing structure ensures that there are no hidden costs:

  • Provides a range of pricing plans to suit different firm sizes and requirements.

Detailed Comparison Chart

FeatureSilverfinMyWorkpapers
Problems SolvedAutomates compliance, centralises client data, ensures accuracySimplifies audit/year-end, enhances collaboration
Ease of UseUser-friendly, integrated communication toolsIntuitive platform, PDF annotation, Excel integration
Time SavingsLive data syncs, AI-powered error checks, AI data mappingAutomated workflows, centralised data
FlexibilityTailored workflows and templatesStandard/custom templates, personalised processes
IntegrationsXero, QuickBooks, Sage, open APIs plus many moreIRIS, Sage, QuickBooks, secure portals
AI Data AnalysisAI for discrepancies, continuous monitoring, data mappingN/A
PricingFlexible per client file pricingVarious plans

The Verdict: Silverfin’s AI Edge

Both Silverfin and MyWorkpapers offer robust solutions for accounting firms, but Silverfin’s advanced AI capabilities undoubtedly give it an edge. 

Silverfin excels in automation and AI-driven data analysis, making it ideal for firms looking to enhance accuracy and reduce manual tasks. This not only will give your accounting firm a competitive edge but is a future-proofing leap forward in accounting technology for ambitious firms.

With 43% of firms moving towards a virtual-only presence, adopting a cloud-first, automated tool is more critical than ever. Add AI power to this with Silverfin and the sky is the limit. 

Keen to explore the possibilities of Silverfin in more detail? Book a chat. 

Download Whitepaper now: Do you deserve more than Excel? Moving working papers beyond spreadsheets

More Posts

silverfin

Silverfin partners with Docusign giving accountancy firms seamless documentation in the cloud

Discover how Silverfin and Docusign’s integration streamlines electronic signing, enhancing workflow efficiency through the cloud.
Read More
The future of AI in accounting

The AI Advantage: Why AI and Accountancy Goes Hand in Hand

Accounting firms face the dual challenge of managing burgeoning data while maintaining precision and compliance. As regulatory landscapes become more complex and client demands for ...
Read More

Artificial intelligence in accounting: market trends for 2025 and beyond 

Explore the evolving role of artificial intelligence in accounting in the UK, with our market outlook for 2025 and beyond.
Read More

How Gravita is pioneering the AI evolution in accounting

Discover how UK accounting firm, Gravita is leveraging AI to automate manual processes and free up time to focus on value-added services.
Read More

How cloud-based accounting software can improve your firm

Discover the benefits of cloud-based accounting software—improve accuracy, efficiency, and collaboration with real-time data and automation.
Read More

Simplifying Tax Seasons: How To Automate Tax Workpaper Preparation

Tax season often means long hours, extensive paperwork, and an increased risk of human error. Tax workpaper automation offers a way to streamline these processes, ...
Read More

The Benefits of Digital Working Papers for Accountants

The use of working papers in accountancy started in the 19th century at the beginning of modern accountancy, and have evolved significantly over time.  First ...
Read More

How AI technologies are revolutionising accounting firms in the UK

AI is transforming accounting firms in the UK by automating tasks, enhancing data accuracy and boosting productivity. Here's how.
Read More

Elevating Efficiency: Customer Portals Transform Workflows for Accounting Firms & Boost Customer Service

Ideally, a customer portal for accounting firms is a secure cloud-based platform that can improve how you interact with your clients. With a seamless exchange ...
Read More

EP 6 – AI implementation at FreeAgent: Insights from Stu McEwan, FreeAgent

In the latest episode of the Silver Linings podcast, Stuart McEwan, Staff Product Manager at FreeAgent, shared valuable insights about implementing AI in accounting software. ...
Read More
The best AI tools for accounting firm

What’s new and useful? The latest AI innovations and what to use them for

In this chapter from our recent AI whitepaper ‘Beyond the hype: the real benefits of AI for your accountancy firm’, we check our understanding of ...
Read More

Simplifying Tax Seasons: How To Automate Tax Workpaper Preparation

Tax season often means long hours, extensive paperwork, and an increased risk of human error. Tax workpaper automation offers a way to streamline these processes, ...
Read More

Let’s Chat

Scroll to Top